⚠️ Organic Valley decided not to produce eggnog for the 2021 holiday season 😔
If you think you don’t like eggnog, maybe you just haven’t tried this one yet. I did a hardcore taste test a decade ago and have yet to find a better alternative. It's so good, I never accept defeat if it's unavailable at my usual grocery stores.
This is worthy of a scavenger hunt (though I think you can pretty reliably find it at Whole Foods).
(The only other one I would be willing to serve to guests is the one from TJ's, but it's a distant second.)
To turn it into a cocktail, just add brandy (or rum?)
I’ve seen people dust the top with nutmeg (freshly grated on a microplane if possible); just don’t overdo or it will be gritty.